Skip to content
SwiftBurst

The NYC grocery field guide

Milk in Manhattan

Milk offers need the same container size and dairy type to make a useful comparison. A half-gallon specialty carton and a gallon of conventional milk serve different buying decisions.

Read the available Manhattan source records below, then match the package and conditions to what you plan to buy.

Open free comparison

Comparison starts with staples. Add items from the shopping list in the app.

Before you buyManhattan
THE NEXT GROCERY RUNNYC

Milk.
The details matter.

01
Match whole, reduced-fat or skim milk and the container volume.
02
Separate lactose-free, organic and ultra-filtered milk from conventional cartons.
03
Check the sell-by date and whether your household can finish the larger container.

Match what you actually buy.A different package, preparation or purchase condition can change the decision.

Before you go

Read the source.
Keep the conditions with the price.

01

Check the milk you mean.

Start with the version and quantity on your list. A matching search term does not make two packages interchangeable. These are the details to carry into a comparison.

  • Check 1Match whole, reduced-fat or skim milk and the container volume.
  • Check 2Separate lactose-free, organic and ultra-filtered milk from conventional cartons.
  • Check 3Check the sell-by date and whether your household can finish the larger container.
Keep the gaps visible

If a record leaves out the package or coupon requirements, that information is missing. Do not assume a unit price, an automatic discount or a product substitution. Open the store record and confirm the exact item before making a trip.

02

Read the weekly-ad records.

These records come from weekly-ad circulars for listed Manhattan locations. The printed price stays with its package, conditions and ad end date. A circular record does not confirm that the item is on the shelf.

FARMLAND ORGANIC MILK

  • Printed price$5.99
  • PackageFat Free, 2% or Whole 1/2 Gal. Cntr.
  • ConditionsNo condition information supplied; check with the store
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsBravo Supermarket Madison Ave, 1588 Madison Avenue

Parmalat Whole Milk 32 fl oz

  • Printed price2/$6
  • PackageNot supplied by this source
  • Conditions1%, 2% or fat free
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsCherry Valley Marketplace 2nd Ave, 1968 2nd Avenue

PARMALAT MILK

LACTAID MILK

  • Printed price$6.99
  • PackageNot supplied by this source
  • ConditionsNo condition information supplied; check with the store
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsCTown St Nicholas Ave, 1016 St Nicholas Ave

Horizon Organic 0% Fat Free Milk, 64 fl oz Half Gallon Carton

Horizon Organic DHA Omega-3 2% Reduced Fat Milk, 64 fl oz Half Gallon Carton

Horizon Organic Lactose Free 2% Reduced Fat Milk, 64 fl oz Half Gallon Carton

Horizon Organic Whole Milk, 64 fl oz Half Gallon Carton

Farmland Fresh Dairies Organic Shelf Stable Milk

  • Printed price6/$4
  • PackageNot supplied by this source
  • ConditionsAssorted - 8 oz
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsFood Bazaar East 125th St, 201 East 125th St

Mooala Organic Milk

  • Printed price$5.99
  • PackageNot supplied by this source
  • ConditionsAssorted 48 oz
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsFood Bazaar East 125th St, 201 East 125th St

Stonyfield Organic Milk

  • Printed price$4.99
  • PackageNot supplied by this source
  • ConditionsAssorted - 64 oz
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsFood Bazaar East 125th St, 201 East 125th St

Organic Valley Milk

Silk Milk

Fairlife Milk

  • Printed price$4.99
  • Package52 oz
  • ConditionsAll varieties
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsIdeal Food Basket 9th Ave, 317 9th Avenue

Fairlife Milk

  • Printed price$4.99
  • Package52 oz
  • ConditionsNo condition information supplied; check with the store
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsIdeal Food Basket Lexington Ave, 1635 Lexington Avenue

A2 Milk

  • Printed price$4.99
  • Package59 oz
  • Conditions2% Reduced Fat or Whole
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsLincoln Market Manhattan, 223 Saint Nicholas Avenue

Lactaid milk, 52-64oz carton, all varieties

A2 Milk

  • Printed price$4.99
  • Package59 oz. cont.
  • ConditionsNo condition information supplied; check with the store
  • SourceWeekly-ad circular · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Ad valid through
  • Listed locationsPioneer Supermarket Columbus Ave, 289 Columbus Avenue
03

Keep shelf and catalog records separate.

These records come from shelf-price or store catalogs. They are listed separately from circular promotions because their source and validity differ. The observation time is when the source record was captured; the page snapshot time does not refresh that record.

CREAM O LAND 1% LOW FAT MILK / 128 FL OZ (128 FL OZ)

  • Printed price$5.49
  • PackageNot supplied by this source
  • ConditionsNo condition information supplied; check with the store
  • SourceShelf-price catalog · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Record valid through
  • Listed locationsBrooklyn Fare Greenwich St, 666 Greenwich Street
    Brooklyn Fare West 37th St, 431 West 37th Street
    Brooklyn Fare West End Ave, 75 West End Avenue

CREAM O LAND 1% LOW FAT MILK / 32 FL OZ (32 FL OZ)

  • Printed price$1.89
  • PackageNot supplied by this source
  • ConditionsNo condition information supplied; check with the store
  • SourceShelf-price catalog · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Record valid through
  • Listed locationsBrooklyn Fare Greenwich St, 666 Greenwich Street
    Brooklyn Fare West 37th St, 431 West 37th Street
    Brooklyn Fare West End Ave, 75 West End Avenue

CREAM O LAND 1% REDUCED FAT MILK / 64 FL OZ (64 FL OZ)

  • Printed price$2.99
  • PackageNot supplied by this source
  • ConditionsNo condition information supplied; check with the store
  • SourceShelf-price catalog · See the linked store record
  • Source observed
  • Record valid through
  • Listed locationsBrooklyn Fare Greenwich St, 666 Greenwich Street
    Brooklyn Fare West 37th St, 431 West 37th Street
    Brooklyn Fare West End Ave, 75 West End Avenue

For the next decision, compare the same quantity and buying conditions. Then consider the extra fare, time and bags for another stop. A single item does not establish the best store for your whole shopping list.

Now use your list

Put the whole trip in view.

Open free comparison to review covered staples. To compare your own list, add items through the shopping list in the app. Keep missing items and mismatched packages visible when deciding where to shop.

Open free comparison
Keep reading

Browse all grocery guides, see Manhattan stores and weekly deals, or read how to compare your actual shopping list.

For the things you buy again

Your usuals.
Worth keeping an eye on.

Exclusive Deal Alerts watches up to 15 grocery items for matching offers in your NYC area. At most one alert email a day. It is an optional paid service.

See Exclusive Deal Alerts ↗

The source note

Page snapshot: . Each published record shows its own source observation and validity. The snapshot time describes page assembly, not a new check of every store. Circular, shelf-price and store-catalog records have different coverage and may omit products or locations.

The records are a selection of source evidence, not an exhaustive borough inventory or a cheapest-store ranking. Check the linked source or store for final terms, price and availability.